Services

Markets

Company

Resources

Pricing

Sign Up
🇺🇸

EN

Home
/US Property Taxes
/New York
/Cayuga County

Cayuga County Property Taxes: Rates and Bills by City

$774 avg. annual savings
No Upfront Costs
You only pay if we save

In tax year 2026, the median Cayuga County homeowner paid $3,048 in property taxes, a median effective rate of 1.94% of market value, compared with 1.90% statewide. New York's median bill is among the highest in the country, driven by high home values and school taxes.

In Cayuga County, rates range from 1.00% in Cortland to 2.24% in Montezuma.

  • Median Cayuga County effective property tax rate: 1.94%
  • Median Cayuga County home value: $168,636
  • Median Cayuga County property tax bill: $3,048

Last Updated October 26, 2026

  • Property Tax Calculator
  • Overview
  • Rates and Bills
  • FAQs
  • Find Your City

Cayuga County Property Tax Calculator

$100,000

$1,500,000

$3,000,000

Median Effective Tax Rate

1.94%

Estimate Property Tax Bill

$3,272

$3,036

How Property Taxes Work in Cayuga County

In Cayuga County, property is assessed by your city or town assessor (except in Nassau County and New York City, which operate centralized assessment systems). Many municipalities assess at a fraction of market value rather than 100%, so New York State publishes an equalization rate for each town or city to make values comparable.

Your bill combines county, town or city, school district, and special district taxes. School taxes make up the largest share of most bills. Local tax levy growth is generally capped at 2% or inflation, whichever is lower, though voters and local boards can override it.

Property Tax Bills in Cayuga County

Source: Ownwell

$1,465

$4,422

$7,379

Our median effective property tax rate (tax bill ÷ assessor's market value) accounts for exemptions and deductions, making it more accurate than the general median tax rate, which is the midpoint of statutory rates before adjustments.

Median Cayuga County Effective Property Tax Rate

1.94%

Median Cayuga County Home Value

$168,636

Median Cayuga County Tax Bill

$3,048

What is the Median Effective Property Tax Rate?

Our median effective property tax rate (tax bill ÷ assessor's market value) accounts for exemptions and deductions, making it more accurate than the general median tax rate, which is the midpoint of statutory rates before adjustments. Because New York municipalities assess at different fractions of market value, the effective rate is the only fair way to compare bills across Cayuga County and the state.

Property Tax Rates and Bills by City

RankCityMedian Effective Tax RateMedian Home ValueMedian Tax Bill25th % Bill75th % Bill90th % Bill
1Homer1.76%$525,231$7,379$4,705$10,278$16,103
2Skaneateles1.73%$329,077$4,885$2,802$9,596$14,613
3Aurora1.56%$247,375$4,039$2,852$6,022$10,058
4Cayuga1.95%$197,470$3,972$2,532$6,036$8,668
5King Ferry1.64%$262,500$3,891$2,371$6,160$9,114
6Weedsport2.24%$174,846$3,874$2,666$5,281$6,906
7Moravia1.94%$195,379$3,754$2,267$5,626$8,365
8Hannibal2.08%$169,714$3,594$2,129$4,338$5,535
9Union Springs1.81%$191,700$3,536$2,658$5,070$7,459
10Scipio Center1.57%$189,046$3,043$2,071$4,391$6,272
11Cato2.06%$147,500$2,992$1,899$4,292$5,999
12Auburn2.05%$163,333$2,978$1,960$4,740$7,839
13Oswego1.41%$176,897$2,977$1,938$5,084$7,230
14Jordan2.06%$170,000$2,854$1,594$4,605$6,526
15Locke1.76%$164,599$2,713$1,570$3,893$5,143
16Port Byron2.08%$127,821$2,700$1,693$3,859$5,307
17Baldwinsville1.97%$135,571$2,638$2,321$3,895$4,565
18Genoa1.61%$158,250$2,426$1,663$4,077$5,866
19Montezuma2.24%$119,149$2,353$1,618$3,287$4,238
20Meridian1.98%$130,000$2,260$1,682$3,383$3,720
21Fair Haven1.05%$197,845$2,053$1,165$3,795$5,426
22Sterling1.08%$165,000$2,050$1,253$3,501$5,340
23Groton1.00%$179,934$2,046$1,269$3,020$4,489
24Martville1.70%$131,429$1,872$1,017$3,276$5,323
25Cortland1.00%$166,154$1,635$1,021$2,540$3,419
26Red Creek1.08%$131,769$1,465$957$2,158$3,238
—ElbridgeN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
—LansingN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
—SavannahN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A

Source: Ownwell

How to Grieve Your Property Taxes in Cayuga County

In New York, an assessment appeal is called a grievance. You can grieve if your assessment exceeds your home's market value, exceeds similar homes nearby, or if you were denied an exemption.

  1. 1

    Review your assessment notice

    Most towns publish a tentative assessment roll on May 1 (May 1 across most of New York; January in Nassau County and New York City). Review your home's taxable value and property details.

  2. 2

    File a grievance

    File Form RP-524 with your Board of Assessment Review (BOR) by Grievance Day (the fourth Tuesday in May). In most of New York, Grievance Day is the fourth Tuesday in May (the third Tuesday in June in Suffolk and Westchester; March 1 in Nassau County; March 15 for Class 1 homes in NYC).

  3. 3

    Review and decision

    The board reviews evidence from you and your city or town assessor, such as comparable sales or an appraisal, and issues a determination.

  4. 4

    Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR)

    Owners of one- to three-family homes who disagree with the decision can file for SCAR, a low-cost hearing before an independent hearing officer, usually within 30 days of the final assessment roll.

  5. 5

    Further appeal

    Owners of commercial properties or homeowners seeking further review can file an Article 7 petition in state Supreme Court.

New York Property Tax Exemptions

The School Tax Relief (STAR) program is the most common form of property tax relief in New York. New homeowners receive STAR as a state credit check or direct deposit rather than an exemption on their bill, while Enhanced STAR provides a larger benefit for income-eligible seniors.

New York also offers local options for seniors with limited incomes, veterans, and people with disabilities. File exemptions with your city or town assessor, usually by the taxable status date (March 1, which is March 1 in most towns; January 2 in Nassau County; January 5 in NYC), per NYS Department of Taxation and Finance guidelines.

Key Dates

DateWhat Happens
March 1Taxable status date; exemption applications due (March 1 in most NY towns)
May 1Tentative assessment roll published (May 1 in most NY towns)
Grievance Day (the fourth Tuesday in May)Grievance deadline / Grievance Day
July 1Final assessment roll filed (July 1 in most NY towns)
30 days after final rollSmall Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) filing deadline
September to JanuarySchool, town, and county tax bills due (varies by municipality)

Frequently Asked Property Tax Questions in Cayuga County

What is the average property tax rate in Cayuga County?
The median effective property tax rate in Cayuga County is 1.94% of a home's market value. On the median Cayuga County home value of $168,636, that's about $3,272 per year. Rates range from 1.00% in Cortland to 2.24% in Montezuma.
Which city in Cayuga County has the highest and lowest property taxes?
Montezuma has the highest median effective property tax rate in the county at 2.24%, while Cortland has the lowest effective rate at 1.00%.
Why are property taxes so high in Cayuga County?
New York relies heavily on local property taxes to fund public schools, and many communities have high property values. Bills also combine multiple taxing layers, including your county, town or city, school district, and special districts like fire and library services.
When is the property tax grievance deadline in Cayuga County?
The grievance deadline is Grievance Day (the fourth Tuesday in May). For most New York towns, Grievance Day is the fourth Tuesday in May. In Suffolk and Westchester counties, it is typically the third Tuesday in June; in Nassau County, it is March 1; and in New York City, it is March 15 for one- to three-family homes.
What is the STAR exemption in New York?
STAR reduces school taxes on a primary residence. Basic STAR is available to most homeowners earning under the state income limit, while Enhanced STAR provides an increased benefit for qualifying seniors 65 and older.
What is SCAR in Cayuga County?
Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) is an affordable appeal process for owners of one- to three-family homes who disagree with their Board of Assessment Review grievance determination. An independent hearing officer reviews the case.
Is it worth grieving property taxes in Cayuga County?
Yes. If your assessment exceeds your home's true market value or is higher than comparable properties in your town, grieving your assessment can meaningfully lower your property tax bill.

Find Your City

A

AuburnAurora

B

Baldwinsville

C

CatoCayugaCortland

F

Fair Haven

G

GenoaGroton

H

HannibalHomer

J

Jordan

K

King Ferry

L

Locke

M

MartvilleMeridianMontezumaMoravia

O

Oswego

P

Port Byron

R

Red Creek

S

Scipio CenterSkaneatelesSterling

U

Union Springs

W

Weedsport
Property Tax Appeals Property Tax Exemptions Commercial Tax Appeals Tax Bill Payments Ownwell Energy Home Insurance Bill Reduction Talk to Tax Expert
Residential Single Family Rentals Commercial
California Colorado Florida Georgia Illinois New York Pennsylvania Texas Washington
About Pricing Careers Become a Partner
2026 Texas Results Ownwell Comparisons Blog Case Studies Property Tax Insights Property Tax Trends Testimonials Templates Glossary Cancel Non-Ownwell Service
Help Center FAQs
Help Center FAQs

Percent of customers who received a reduction on at least one appeal in 2025 as of 12/31/2025

Average savings of customers who saved on at least one property in 2025 as of 12/31/2025

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | GLBA | Accessibility | Disclosures

Your Privacy Choices

© 2026 Ownwell, Inc. All rights reserved.

🇺🇸 English

🇲🇽 Español

4.7

Based on 3,000+ reviews